The Big Picture: Sean Carroll

Included in this review: Book: The Big Picture:On the Origins of Life, Meaning, and the Universe Itself . Interview: www.closertotruth.com/series/physics-free-will I include Carroll’s book in my list of “Classic Texts” because it may be taken as the standard account, for non-specialists, of what naturalism/physicalism means for moral philosophy and the challenge it poses to traditional values. It’s … Read more

Evolution, A View from the 21st Century: Shapiro

The Modern Synthesis is dead. Evolution doesn’t take place the way we thought it did, the way we make a building out of individual bricks—genetic mutations— added one at a time through the action of natural selection. Instead it happens more the way we build a bridge, out of long sections already fully functional and … Read more

The Selfish Gene, by Richard Dawkins

What a misfortune, for all concerned! I recently adopted the skeptical stance of refusing to believe anything I needed maths to understand. And now, just a few weeks later, I undertake to review Dawkins’ “The Selfish Gene”! Dawkins and his primary sources, his “Bad Boys,” George Williams, W. D. Hamilton, John Maynard Smith and Robert … Read more

Mind and Nature: Gregory Bateson

The rise of modern genetics banished from evolutionary thinking the contributions of such figures as Samuel Butler, William Bateson and Teilhard de Chardin. Later in the 20th century Gregory Bateson, William’s son, revived them. William Bateson: “We commonly think of animals and plants as matter, but they are really systems through which matter is constantly … Read more

The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection by Ronald A. Fisher

Review of the second revised edition Why is this book important? Because it is still referred to as the basis for the population statistics on which rests the reigning scientific theory of evolution. As recently as 2010 Fisher was Richard Dawkins’ choice for the greatest biologist since Darwin: “He therefore could be said to have … Read more

The Material Basis of Evolution, by Richard Goldschmidt

I came to Goldschmidt’s book having only two associations with his name—a distinction between microevolution and macroevolution, and the term “hopeful monsters.” I found the former to be central to his thinking: his book is divided into two parts, headed respectively “Microevolution” and “Macroevolution.” The phrase “Hopeful monsters” he employs only in a final chapter, … Read more

Biological Principles, by Woodger

Biological Principles: A Critical Study by Joseph Henry Woodger. The following brief review consists of lightly edited extracts from a much longer review “Rethinking Woodger’s Legacy in the Philosophy of Biology,” Journal of the History of Biology (2014) 47:243–292 by Daniel J. Nicholson and Richard Gawne. We have Dr. Nicholson’s permission to quote extensively from the article. Readers are urged … Read more